Isn’t a human life worth more than a plant’s? Humans need plants to survive though. And we’re destroying the earth by not caring for plants. But isn’t climate change just a myth? Hmm… this isn’t so obvious after all...
Humans or plants: who’s winning?
What fraction of our current plant species are at risk of extinction during the 21st century?
Climate change, habitat modification, deforestation and pollution all put pressure on the world’s plant species. We can expect to lose two-thirds of all plant species on Earth. The curiously named ‘Quiver Tree’ – native to South Africa and Nambia – may be one of the first trees to go.
The Amazon rainforest occupies about 40% of South America, and is the biggest tropical rainforest in the world. The UK and Ireland would fit inside it 17 times! What percentage of the Amazon rainforest has been lost in the last 50 years?
Tropical rainforests like the Amazon are so important as they have amazing biodiversity – a huge range of plant and animal life. Should they be allowed to be destroyed?
Acid rain is caused by chemicals (sulphur dioxide and nitrogen oxides) which react with water and oxygen to create acid rain which damages plants and animals. So where do these chemicals come from in the first place?
Burning fossil fuels creates these chemical pollutants which cause acid rain. As well as harming plants and animals, acid rain can corrode steel and damage stone buildings.
Established forests store a huge amount of carbon. This is so important because it means the carbon is not released into the atmosphere, where it can contribute to global warming. Just how much CO2 is removed by forests each year?
That’s the same as 1/3 of our current CO2 emissions from burning fossil fuels. It’s difficult to predict exactly how much CO2 forests remove, but they certainly have a huge role to play in removing CO2 from our atmosphere.
It is predicted that the Earth will warm by between 2 and 6 Degrees Celsius in the next 100 years. What effect do you think global warming will have on plants?
Depending on the plant species and its environment, global warming can have a range of effects. It would be great if all plants could adapt to their changing environment, but in reality lots are likely to become extinct. Scientists believe that a 4C rise would kill 85% of the Amazon rainforest - even a more modest temperature rise would see a 20-40% loss within 100 years.
From forests and grasslands to oceans and rivers, plants have an essential role to play. They also provide us with food, medicines, shelter and fuel. But just how many plant species have we found on Earth?
390,000- plus scientists are constantly discovering new plants too. In 2015, over 2,000 new plant species were discovered!
Deforestation is the removal of forest or trees. It releases greenhouse gases, kills plants and animals (and of course trees), and can even affect the climate. So why are we still clearing trees?
There are lots of reason why deforestation is happening. With more people on the planet, we need more food, products and homes – and all of these can drive deforestation.
Humans vs Trees
Paramedics attending the scene of a car that’s crashed into a tree will automatically focus their efforts on saving the people in the car. They won’t check the tree for signs of life and try to bring it back the way they will a human. We assume people matter more than trees. But maybe we need to think about why. After all, we couldn’t survive without trees while they’d do just fine without us… they wouldn’t have cars crashing into them for a start!
Dr. Joshua Shepherd (Philosophy Department at the University of Oxford) points out that some rare plants have needed humans to cultivate (look after) them so they would not have existed without human intervention. “But generally speaking if we all died, plants would continue to live.” This maybe makes us think just a little differently about that tree destroyed by the human driving a car.
So what makes us think we're more important than plants?
“In philosophy, there’s the technical term ‘moral status’ which means you have a reason for treating something a certain way,” says Dr Shepherd. So if a living being can feel pain or joy it’s deemed to have value and should be treated with respect.
Humans are thought to have the highest level of moral status but some environmental activists disagree. “Some plants have a high status, for example, the rainforest or plants from which we get food. And many medicines come from plants. But do you keep plants alive just for human survival rather than in their own right? It depends on your value system,” he says.
Trees are alive, an ecosystem in their own right and an important part of our environment. But, conflicts between trees and people often happen. This can be due to a tree’s natural growth endangering human life, such as an overgrown branch hanging over a pavement or playground. And conflict can result from human activities impacting on trees - such as that car crash we mentioned at the beginning.
But trees, like humans, also have medics to look after them. It’s a tree surgeon’s job to maintain the health and welfare of trees. So humans help trees - the development of tree surgery indicates some people care about them a great deal. Many keen gardeners will tell you talking to their plants helps them grow. And even if it doesn’t, people enjoy growing them and having them in their homes and gardens. We get enormous pleasure from plant life.
People are thought to be a higher evolved form of life than plants because we can experience and give great joy. We’re presumed to have a high degree of intelligence and sophistication and to make rational choices. Yet, some argue that humans aren’t always rational and can cause great suffering as well as joy. Whereas plants never set out to deliberately harm us - except in sci-fi novels such as ‘The Day Of the Triffids’ (by John Wyndham) when plants take over and kill people! Maybe the reason why this story is so popular is that it touches upon a deep fear that plants might one day fight back?
“We assume humans are vastly more important than plants but when you start to think of why that is, you can get to some interesting places,” adds Dr Shepherd. “For some people, all life matters. That would be the argument from environmental philosophers. Some argue you shouldn’t mess with nature unless you have a very good reason, e.g. human life is at risk”.
So why should we take care of plants?
“Some plants may be very rare or particularly beautiful. So it could be argued we have a duty to preserve them. They also give people enjoyment in national parks. Activists are highly motivated to protect the rainforest for this reason.”
In the video below Professor Katherine Willis (The Oxford Martin School) explains more about why the different plants and natural landscapes are so important to us and all life on Earth.
But it's not that simple...
People who live in or near the rainforest may argue they need to chop some of it down to build homes, create jobs and earn a living to provide for their families. Do people in the developed world have the right to demand that people in the developing world don’t build over their natural environments?
“Some land is considered sacred by native Americans or Australians. It isn’t possible to preserve everything but respecting the wishes of people whose ancestors once occupied a land is something we ought to think about,” says Dr Shepherd.
There’s a similar argument about destroying areas of natural beauty or of special scientific significance to build a new road, train line or runway. Those in favour tend to argue such developments benefit everyone as they bring jobs and money to the area. And maybe make it easier to get to work or fly abroad on holiday. But unless local people feel a direct benefit, the loss of a much-loved beauty spot can be devastating.
“There is some evidence of plants demonstrating long term memory and learning. For example in an experiment people dropped plants to see how they reacted. It was seen that this damaged parts of their internal system. They then withdrew their leaves in reaction. But over time they were seen to adapt and grow back again. Also, roots of trees and plants will search out and find water needed for nourishment but that doesn’t mean they function the way humans do. Plants have internal functioning mechanisms but this is nothing like a human or animal brain,” says Dr Shepherd.
Some people argue that just because a living organism doesn’t function the same way we do is no excuse for not respecting its right to life. There needs to be a balance between competing needs.
Diverse plant life is vital for our existence. It provides everything we need for life on earth. However, there are enormous pressures on our ecosystem from global warming and land-use change (such as mining for coal and precious materials, drilling for gas or oil (‘fracking'), and building new homes). And we should perhaps value plants and trees for their own right to life. “It’s all about managing conflict when different values and needs are in tension,” concludes Dr Shepherd.
Can you think of ways to treat plants fairly while thinking of human needs too? It’s a tricky one…
5 plants that have helped us treat diseases
-
The Spanish discovered in the 17th century in what is now Peru that the bark of the cinchona tree was used by the indigenous people to cure “fevers”, especially malaria. At that time the European “treatment” for malaria was to throw the feverish patient head first into a bush and they had to get out quickly enough to leave the fever behind! Quinine was purified from bark extracts in 1820, and it was found that it could prevent as well as treat malaria. It was an essential tool in the spread of the British Empire around that time. Colonists in regions like India had to take daily doses of quinine, and eventually started mixing it with soda and water to make the bitter powder taste better, and “tonic water” was born. It wasn’t long before the daily dose of quinine in tonic water seemed much better mixed with gin, and the quintessential gin and tonic was used thereafter by colonists to stay safe in the hot, humid environments they were living in. Quinine is also used to treat lupus and arthritis.
-
A beautiful pink flower from the island of Madagascar, off the east coast of Africa, the “rosy periwinkle” as it is commonly known, was long used by traditional healers for diabetes, and in Chinese traditional medicine to treat diabetes, malaria and Hodgkin’s lymphoma, a type of blood and lymph cancer. In the 1950s two compounds from the plant were isolated – vincristine and vinblastine – which were found to have anti-cancer properties. Since the 1960s, these drugs have been used to treat blood cancers and have improved survival rates from 1 in 5 to 9 in 10! It takes 900 kg to make just one gram of the drug though, so pharmaceutical companies had to cultivate the plants on a large scale. Nowadays, however, vincristine and vinblastine are made synthetically.
-
Also known as “naked lady”, meadow saffron produces a chemical called colchicine, used to treat gout, a kind of arthritis caused by a build-up of uric acid crystals in the joints. The joints become red, hot and swollen. The drug is also used to treat a type of genetic inflammatory disease called familial Mediterranean fever, where symptoms include swelling of large joints, stomach pain, and inflammation of the lining of the lungs, making it difficult to breathe or lie flat. Nobody really knows how the drug works, but it does. It was first described as a treatment for rheumatism and swelling on an Egyptian medical papyrus in 1500 BC. It was first used as a treatment for gout in the first century AD, but the drug was only isolated from the plant by two French chemists in 1820. Side effects include numbness and tingling of the hands and feet, and overdose causes burning in the mouth and throat, fever, vomiting and diarrhoea. This demonstrates the powerful actions that some plants can have on the body, and why it is so important to preserve the plants we have in case we discover more medicines.
-
The active ingredient in aspirin is called acetylsalicylic acid, and it comes from the leaves (or bark) of the white willow tree. Aspirin has been around for centuries for the treatment of pain, fevers, inflammation, and even those who have had a heart attack. It reduces pain and inflammation and also thins the blood. It has even been used to reduce the risk of getting cancer and dying from cancer, mostly colorectal cancer. The use of willow leaf extracts has been known since ancient times when the benefits were inscribed on clay tablets in ancient Egypt, and it has been a major asset to the medical world. Unfortunately, some side effects are ulcers in the stomach and using it way too much can cause deafness. One interesting fact about aspirin was its effect on the son of the last czar of Russia, Alexei Nikolaevich Romanov, who had haemophilia, a blood-thinning disease. Since aspirin thins the blood, which is why it is useful for heart attacks, it made his haemophilia worse. The mystic Rasputin suggested he should rely on spiritual treatments, not modern medicine, and Rasputin’s influence on the family is said to have led ultimately to the uprising against the czar, and the end of czarist Russia.
-
Reserpine, a drug isolated from the roots of the smooth-stemmed herb Rauwolfia serpentine, is a very effective medication used to treat hypertension (high blood pressure) and psychotic disorders. The plant has been used in India for 4000 years as a treatment for snake and insect bites, malaria, abdominal pain, and dysentery. Even Mahatma Gandhi used to take Rauwolfia tea as a way to relax in the evenings. It is also said to have anti-depressive properties. Reserpine was first isolated in 1952, but unfortunately, despite its great success as a blood pressure drug, its use has been phased out because of interactions and side-effects, which include a stuffy nose, nausea, dizziness, vomiting, stomach cramps, and even, unexpectedly, depression!
6 ways we could change our lifestyles to help the environment
-
From ice cream and margarine to shampoo and lipstick, Palm Oil is everywhere. It’s in about half of all packaged products at the supermarket, and makes things more ‘creamy’ – but at what cost? The Oil Palm Tree only grows in the tropics and was originally grown in West Africa on small-scale family farms. As demand for processed food and make-up has grown, demand for Palm Oil has too. Now it’s grown in huge plantations mostly in Indonesia and Malaysia. Lots of tropical forests have been cleared to make way for these plantations. In Southeast Asia, 45% of plantations used to be tropical forests. Tropical forests are home to some of the most precious and diverse plants and animals on our planet. Plus, our use of Palm Oil is going up – putting more and more forests at risk. So should you give up ice cream? It’s not quite that simple. Not all ice cream contains Palm Oil (some contain corn or rape seed oil instead), and some will contain Palm Oil that’s sustainably sourced. Just take a look at the label to find out. Though if you do decide to quit Palm Oil, it’s likely that the alternative will be more expensive. Is that a price you’re willing to pay?
-
Flying abroad produces a lot of GHG emissions. It’s not easy to work out, but roughly 100 g of CO2 is produced for each kilometre you fly. For a return flight from London to Rome, that’s about 300 kg of CO2. Although planes have become cleaner as technology has improved, we’re flying more and more. As a result, GHG emissions from flights in Europe increased by 87% between 1990 and 2006. A number of companies now offer ‘carbon offsetting’ against flights. You can pay for a company to plant trees or invest in renewable energy to ‘balance out’ the CO2 produced by your flight. But maybe it’s better just not to fly at all? You could try using a more environmentally friendly form of transport e.g. electric trains? Or perhaps you can try to persuade your family to take holidays closer to home?
-
Producing meat requires a huge amount of energy and releases damaging greenhouse gases (GHG). These GHGs contribute to global warming – with negative effects on plants and whole ecosystems. But why is meat so bad for the environment? It’s all to do with efficiency. To produce meat, we need space to rear the animals and space to grow trees (or other plants) to feed them until they’re big enough for slaughter. Large areas of forest have had to be cleared to make way for this type of farming, which has destroyed the natural habitats of plants and wildlife across the world. Plus, not to forget, the pollution created when transporting the animal food and animals themselves. So should you give up burgers? Or even give up meat, eggs and dairy and go fully vegan? The choice is yours. But reducing the amount of meat you eat can definitely reduce your impact on the environment. It is predicted that if we all adopted a mostly vegetarian diet, we could cut food-related GHG emissions by 63%.
-
What about switching off your laptop? Or your TV? Or just remembering to turn off the lights?
Most of UK electricity is produced by burning fossil fuels – in coal, gas and oil-fired power plants. And all of this releases damaging greenhouse gases. Making small changes to reduce your energy use can all add up. Turn off lights, take shorter showers, turn off your laptop and your TV. It’s important to remember that lots of devices use energy even when they’re in power-save mode.
-
What does organic actually mean? Organic food is produced by using fewer chemicals. Instead of chemicals, organic farmers rely on more natural methods like weeding and spreading manure to produce good crops. Choosing organic fruit and veg could help reduce your impact on the environment – particularly the plant life and ecosystems in rivers and lakes. The chemicals used by non-organic farmers to produce bigger and better crops can run-off into rivers and lakes and lead to 'eutrophication'. This means the water has too many nutrients, so algae blooms and less sunlight reaches other plants. The end result can be the death of many plants and fish. Reducing the number of chemicals in our water sounds like a great idea, and choosing organic food can help. But it’s not so simple. Organic farming produces less food per square mile of land – as it’s less efficient. With a growing population and more mouths to feed, can we afford to feed everyone organically?
-
Do you normally get a lift in the car to school? Perhaps you have friends who do? Or maybe you take a lift in the car at weekends? Petrol and diesel cars are doubly bad. Not only do they release GHGs which lead to climate change, but burning petrol and diesel also releases pollutants like nitrogen oxides and sulphur dioxides. These pollutants can react in the atmosphere and lead to acid rain which can destroy plants (and animals and even some buildings). These pollutants are also bad for human health, so some cities are looking at becoming car-free in the not-too-distant future. Cycling to school instead of driving seems like the perfect solution. Cycling is good for the environment and your health. But it’s not always safe. If cycling isn’t an option, maybe you could take the bus or train? Or car-share with a friend? All these alternatives should reduce your impact on the environment.
Are humans more important than plants?
Humans are thought to be a higher evolved life form than plants because we can experience and give great joy. We’re also presumed to have a high degree of intelligence and sophistication and to make rational choices.
Dr. Joshua Shepherd (University of Oxford) says “There is some evidence of plants demonstrating long-term memory and learning. For example, in an experiment people dropped plants to see how they reacted. It was seen that this damaged parts of their internal system. They then withdrew their leaves in reaction. But over time they were seen to adapt and grow back again.” Just because a living organism doesn’t function the same way we do is no excuse for not respecting its right to life.
Most of the electricity in the UK is produced by burning fossil fuels – in coal, gas and oil-fired power plants. And all of this releases damaging greenhouse gases. But we need electricity for so many important things - it’s used in hospitals, schools, governments and almost everything that keeps our country running! Could this be more important than a few trees..?
Petrol and diesel cars are bad for the environment. Not only do they release GHGs (Greenhouse gases) which lead to climate change but burning petrol and diesel also releases pollutants like nitrogen oxides and sulphur dioxides. These pollutants can react in the atmosphere and lead to acid rain which can destroy plants (and animals and even some buildings). There are definitely ways we could reduce our carbon footprint, by cycling or using public transport that would be much better for plants without much cost to humans.
People who live in or near the rainforest may argue they need to chop some of it down to build homes, create jobs and earn a living to provide for their families. Some suggest that people in the developed world don’t have the right to demand that people in the developing world don’t build over their natural environments. Plus, building new facilities and infrastructure such as a new road, train line or runway can benefit everyone as they bring jobs and money to an area.
In the future, food production could move to vertical farms and skyscrapers, rooftop gardens or vacant spaces in city centres. Electricity will increasingly come from multiple sources of renewable energy, like wind turbines and solar panels. If we focused our scientific research on finding new ways to live sustainably, we could easily reduce our damage to plants and the environment.